Bagpipes and Orchestra
Bagpipes and
western art diverged in the 1500s, but now it is time to share common
ground once again. Creating a shared area is one of Lindsay's goals as
a composer and performer.
The instruments
Scottish smallpipes are
diatonic, delicate and quiet. They can play acoustically with an
orchestra in halls up to 1000 people, but, having a register and tone
colour like a low clarinet, they never overwhelm, nor are they ever
piercing.
Lowland 'pipes (often called
borderpipes) are louder, with a conical bore chanter, giving an effect
that is more like a cross between an oboe and a highland bagpipe.
Lowland pipes are chromatic, giving tremendous musical possibilities,
and suit playing with a small classical sized orchestra
(2,2,2,2/2/timp/5,4,3,2,1) absolutely perfectly.
English border pipes, sometimes
called half-long bagpipes are slightly softer than lowland pipes in
terms of tone, but they are mostly chromatic, very stable in tuning,
and have the widest range of all bagpipes. Again, perfect for classical
sized orchestras, as well as string quartets and chamber ensembles.
Great Highland Bagpipes...A
best that needs no introduction and is difficult to forget. Though
these pipes tend to offer a huge sound, careful instrumentation can
allow the orchestra to complement the power of the pipes with delicate
fine shading of colour and surprising subtlety.
The challenges
There is a perception that bagpipes are never in tune. This is because
they are sensitive like any other instrument, and the player has no
direct contact with reeds during playing (there is a bag in the way...)
which means that should something unexpected happen, it happens. Ever
improving manufacturing of instruments and reeds, new reed technology,
and a lot of experience help overcome these challenges. An additional
difference has been that bagpipes are traditionally not tuned to equal
temperament, and in some circumstances different tunings were
historically applied for different types of bagpipe music (especially
in piobaireachd). It is possible to tune to equal temperament and there
are chanters made for this purpose now, so this area has been made
easier to manage as well.
The music
Whilst Lindsay has Peter Maxwell Davies's Orkney Wedding and Sunrise
in his repertoire, and was possibly the last person to perform it in
the presence of the composer, he is not by any means limited to this.
Lindsay composes and arranges music for all of the above pipes and
orchestral and western art ensembles. There are suites, medleys, two
borderpipe concertos, a highland pipe concerto, some experimental and
totally chromatic pieces, illustrative pieces (bagpipes are very good
at being illustrative and easily bring images to mind in the listeners)
as well as a few transcriptions.
Lindsay has also composed orchestral works without bagpipes to fill up
a full programme with just his material. Previous concerts have also
featured interesting programming choices such as Henryk Górecki - Three Pieces in Old Style, Grieg's Holberg Suite, Benjamin Britten's Simple Symphony or for larger ensembles, Mendelssohn's Scottish Symphony and Hebrides Overture, Kilar's Krzesany.
The effect
Bagpipes of all types can blend into the overall orchestral sound with
remarkable smoothness and beauty. The very emotive and emotional sounds
that bagpipes are famed for bring a strong and moving effect where
needed, while the sheer power of the highland bagpipes is a tremendous
way to lift up all audiences and send them home on wings!
Lindsay's concerts offer a huge potential variety and remain a talking point for audiences for many years after the event.
Special piece!
In 2018 Lindsay's double concerto for mixed bagpipes and harp was
premiered by the Krakow Philharmonic, conducted by Monika Bachowska. It
has received many performances since and represents 20 minutes of joy,
energy, exuberance and timeless reflection.