Writing for Borderpipes
Overview
When
we say 'bagpipes', most people think of the great highland bagpipes of
Scotland. There are, however, other kinds of bagpipes in common use in
Scotland.
Borderpipes are effectively, but imperfectly, chromatic.
Borderpipes
have a tone similar to a highland bagpipe, but less piercing and less
powerful. They balance perfectly with a string quartet or a small chamber
orchestra. The sound carries far better than smallpipes and for
anything other than very delicate ensembles, these should be the
bagpipes of choice.
Like
highland bagpipes, borderpipes have drones. These are usually tuned to
the bottom note of the chanter, and an octave beneath that. These can
be turned off with the help of corks. Some newer instruments have
special levers which allow the drones to be turned off together, but
you should always check if your piper has this or not, as this is not
standard.
As with highland bagpipes, the melody is played on a 'chanter'.
Important
to note is that borderpipes sound continuously and that repetition of
notes happens by short, sharp movements of the fingers called
'gracenotes' (they differ in reality a little from other traditions'
gracenotes). Gracenotes are also grouped together systematically to
form a whole method of playing. This method gives bagpipe music grammar
and nuance and without gracenotes bagpipe music can sound senseless.
With irregular and unusual gracing, it an also sound senseless and it
is worth to be aware of this and refrain from prescribing extensive
gracings if they can't changed by the performer. Often as with other
instruments, unplayable combinations can be, and often are,
presented.
Borderpipes
typically use a both the standard highland gracings, and the variety of
other possibilities from smallpipes. It should be noted though that the
vast majority of borderpipers started off as highland pipers, went
through smallpipes and finally came to borderpipes, which is why the
whole gamut of Scottish bagpipe gracing can be called upon. Borderpipes
are the most difficult to play of all of the Scottish bagpipes, by a
long margin.
For a complete listing of all the basic gracings used by highland pipers please go to the author's teach yourself bagpipes website where there is a clear explanation of both the musical function and the method of playing each embellishment.
In
addition to these, we can have mordents, trills, vibrato, short runs of
a few notes up to a note and glissando between neighbouring pitches
(upwards only).
Range
Borderpipes
are written at sounding pitch. The basic scale has two sharps, and all
chromaticisms are gained by cross fingering. On account of the fairly
recent addition of these notes to the scale, borderpipers have little
familiarity with less standard fingering, and as a result the composer
should bear this in mind when writing
The basic scale is as below:
| Borderpipes - chanter | Drone
|

|
|
The most common deviations from this are C natural and F natural:
Next
is G sharp. This can be taken in two different ways, and atmospheric
conditions influence which method will be used. Tuning is typically
mostly accurate with these first three extended notes.
Finally,
we have D sharp and B flat. It is best not to double these notes with
anyone else at all playing as tuning is often slightly irregular. And
being aware of an alternative note the player can use should
something go wobbly on stage is always a good idea. Not all pipers can
get these notes (Lindsay has them all and they typically behave very
well, though it is always a nervous thing with these last two).
This gives a total range as follows:
| Borderpipes - chanter |
 |
Basics of Playing
As
noted above, bagpipes sound continuously and use a system of gracenotes
as a kind of musical grammar. By far the safest advice is to leave
gracing up to the performer, or to work closely with a piper when
preparing your score. In the Teach Yourself Method, each
embellishment is described firstly with its musical 'reason to be' and
then shown. It would be wise to read this thoroughly.
Generally
speaking, quickly repeated notes do not sound well on bagpipes unless
they are one of the established embellishments. This is because
gracenotes take time to play and this must be factored into the rhythm.
Other
than that, there are no jumps between notes which are unplayable, nor
any which are particularly difficult to play. Caution should be
exercised when jumping between the less standard fingerings, and also
when jumping between hands (there are reasons why changing between
hands is more difficult than on other bagpipes). Extreme caution should
be exercised when jumping between two non standard fingerings.
Borderpipes
are played with bellows, as opposed to being mouthblown. As
a result, there can sometimes be pumping noises when blowing. This is
not always an issue, but when you write for borderpipes you should be
aware of it. Additionally, as the players elbows move before the sound
begins, it can be very difficult for a borderpiper to lead a chamber
ensemble. If you wish the piper to lead, then leaved extra time for the
others to learn to read his or her movements.
The
conductor, if you are writing for an ensemble, needs to be told to give
the piper early notice to get ready. Just like highland pipes, border
pipes start the drones before the chanter.
Unlike
highland bagpipes, borderpipers can mostly hear what is going on around
them, and the pipes are made at the standard concert pitch of A=440Hz.
They will tune up to A=443 and down a little although this is trickier.
Tuning a borderpipe chanter takes time, but less than the
smallpipes need. The piper cannot allow any moisture on to the
reed. The pitch alters a little after warming the instrument up, and it
is best to have the other musicians tune to the bagpipes after about 15
minutes of playing. Borderpipes can fairly easily be tuned to a
piano, although the chromaticisms may not work out perfectly.
Like smallpipes, borderpipes are extremely stable in tuning, once they have settled.
However, as with highland and smallpipes, if something is going to go
off, the performer has no contact with the reed and cannot correct
problems in situ. A borderpiper has about 20 seconds warning of most
problems...
Staccato effects are not possible.
Vibrato is only used on the highest notes, from F sharp to high A. Any
other vibrato will result in a trill, and not a pretty one.
Extended technique
It is possible to sound the drones without sounding the chanter. This
achieved by playing with a lower pressure which can result in the tone
being unstable, or at worst, can result in the pitch changing
altogether and being unsteady. Unfortunately this is often a question
of atmospheric conditions, but is more stable and reliable than with
smallpipes.
Microtones are available as a portamento going upwards from a note one
hole lower. The pitches will be uncertain but the effect works.
Overtones, or harmonics depend upon the individual piper and bagpipe
(and weather). It is theoretically possible to go into a second octave
with borderpipes, but the tuning is unstable, and the effect is less
than ideal. This is achieved by pinching the thumb into the top hole,
and overblowing. You should only use this effect in consultation with
the piper.
Guidebooks
As with highland bagpipes, there are very few guidebooks available
which can tell you anything about writing music for borderpipes. By far
the best thing to do this direction is to get a hold of some bagpipe
music and listen to recordings, together with reading through the teachyourselfbagpipes site to understand what a 'piper really does.